What
Makes a Writer Happy?
(Ranking
Reader Feedback, 1 to 9)
My Quora posts just
went over 500,000 views recently (Jan 31, 2024). That seems like an
accomplishment of sorts, though writing about it feels a bit
self-centred (i.e. blowing your own horn). But I don't own a cat or
dog, and my son is grown up (waiting on grand-kids, hint, hint,
Scott), so funny pet and cute child content is not currently
possible. Thus I will brag about this instead.
But in order to
make the bragging more palatable, I will write about the various
types of feedback that my writing (and my wife’s) have received and
give some indication of how they differ. I will rank them, because
ranking is fun and people often like that sort of thing. It also
helps to frame matters, which helps to develop the content of the
essay. So here goes.
Note that this all
applies to internet channels for sales and other feedback.
-
1 – Selling Print Book(s)
I know it is a bit old-fashioned, but there is
still something special about selling a print book, via Amazon (or
some other on-line business) that is pretty cool. I think it has to
do with the idea that someone out there will pay a higher price than
you charge for the ebook and that he/she will wait around for your book
to arrive in the mail.
On a few occasions, I have had readers get in
touch with me, desiring a print copy of an ebook. They might want
that because the book will make a nice gift or they might have a
collection of books on that subject. My book about military
engineers in WW2 fell into that category, as did my book about
working one summer on the railroad. In the case of the WW2 book, it
turned out that the reader’s uncle was in the same unit (Royal
Canadian Engineers, 12 Field Company) as my dad. So, symbolically,
it felt a little bit like getting old comrades together.
The fact that someone went to some trouble to get
a print copy of your book is flattering and the idea that you are
helping some person out in this way is very rewarding.
This one is great, too. In the Amazon
marketplace, we tend to sell a lot more ebooks than print books
(about 20 to 1 ratio, I would say). Perhaps that makes it seem a
tiny-bit less special than print books, but it still is a great
feeling.
There are two possibilities here: the regular
ebook and the Kindle Unlimited (KU) read of an ebook.
The latter (KU read) actually lets you see how
well your book was received, since you are paid by the page. Most of
our books have good completion rates, which is very nice. In some
cases, non-completions are understandable. In the case of
non-fiction such as a travel book, the reader may have just wanted to
get a general sense of a subject or a potential trip, without
spending a lot of time on details. With fiction, it may be that it
is just not that reader’s thing (i.e. preferred genre or subject
matter). Also, for a long novel, such as some of my wife’s, you
can make more money than on the royalties for the same book.
In the case of a regular ebook sale, you can be
happy with making some money and supplying a reader with an enjoyable
few hours (you certainly hope so, anyway).
-
3 -Running Successful Promotions
Promotions can be giveaways (they can be run for 5
days of every 90 day period) or time-limited price cuts. The former
gives you some new readers, as does the latter, along with some
money.
If you are lucky, money is not your main reason
for writing, so you don’t worry too much about the “missing
money”. You are just happy to know someone is (hopefully) enjoying
the fruits of your labor. It could well be that the person is on a
tight budget, so you feel good about helping out such a person, even
in this rather small way. My wife often mentions that.
Every now and
again, one of your promotions will go viral. Suddenly you will
notice a big uptick in downloads. Over the next few days, that can
turn into a flood of downloads, which is rather exciting (e.g. in
the 100s, 1000s or more if you are an exceptionally lucky person). You get
to see your book on the “Top 100” list for free books, at least
in some sub-category. Of course you have to keep your wits about
you, and your ego in check. After all, a free promotion is still a
free promotion. But it is nice.
There is really no
(obvious) rhyme or reason to viral promotions. We have had books go
viral, long after they were first published, that have languished up
until then. Other times, they have gone viral right away, then
languished. Often it isn’t the book that you consider your best
writing (stylistically) or your best story (fiction or non-fiction).
You think about the cover, or about the title, or about the summary
that you wrote for it.
“Aha
– people like covers that feature water!”
“Aha
– people like abstract covers with cool fonts!”
“Aha
– people like short, clever titles!”
“Aha
– people like long, wordy titles, that telegraph the content of the
book!”
“Aha
– people like short, pithy blurbs and summaries!”
“Aha
– people like long discursive summaries that explain every
chapter!”
But, in reality,
these things have a logic all of their own. As a famous Hollywood
producer was reported to have said “nobody knows nothing”.
One other thing
about promotions worth mentioning, is that they can lead to later
sales or later concurrent KU reads. I have seen this on many
occasions. I think of it as a little touch of karma – the universe
gives you a small reward for being generous with your books.
-
4 -Getting Reviews or Reader Ratings
Naturally, every
writer likes a nice review or a high rating.
Some people think
that most of the reviews are plants or friends, but that isn’t
often the case, at least as far as I know. I mean, honestly, who has
that many friends? Well, maybe big publishers can get up to these
shenanigans, but that’s out-of-scope for most (all?) Indies.
Even a not-so-great
review is valuable if it is sincere, and if it is clear that the
reader has actually read the book (or at least enough of it to render
a valid judgment). For the writer, it can be valuable feedback. For
the potential reader, some less-than-stellar reviews will provide
reassurance that the reviews are organic and not rigged. And some
potential readers may read something like “I don’t like books
that feature paranormal events” and think “actually, I love books
like that”. You just never know.
Here are a few things that I have learned about reviews and reader ratings:
-
you can generally expect one review/rating for every 50 to 100 books
sold or downloaded in a promo. Sometimes more, sometimes less, but this one percentish rule seems to be quite consistent.
-
the Goodreads scale and the Amazon scale are a bit different, so bear
that in mind when comparing your reviews from these sources.
-
writers love to get reviews and reader ratings, so don’t be shy,
even if you can’t give a 5-star review in all sincerity.
-
a bad review stings for a while, but you get over it.
Social
Media
I try to do some
blogging or equivalent social media content (as you must know from
reading this). It provides an outlet to share ideas, exercise one’s
writing muscles and promote one’s “real writing”.
6) Quora
As the beginning of
this blog indicates, I post fairly regularly on Quora. This is a
social media site run by Google, whereby people ask questions and
others answer them. These often tend to be of a somewhat academic
nature (informally so), where people can share their knowledge and
expertise. Most of my posts are in the area of statistics and data
science, since that is my actual profession, or “day job” as
writers say, perhaps tongue-in-cheek.
Getting views,
comments and upvotes on Quora is a nice lift. It is also nice to
think that you are doing some service in the world, by sharing your
hard-won knowledge with people who are interested in such things.
In principle, you
can make money on Quora, though I doubt that it would amount to much,
even with half-a-million views. I don’t mind sharing my knowledge
for free. I suspect that’s how most people treat Quora. That
said, I might put together some of my best Quora stuff in an ebook at
some future time.
It seems like most
of the Quora numbers are legit (not bots), though I can’t be sure
of that. However, I am suspicious that the big companies (such as
Google) are mining Quora for content to feed their voracious Large
Language Models (AI like ChatGPT).
7) Blogger
A blogging site gives one a chance to just ramble
away on any subject (like I am doing now) and to promote books (like
I will do at the end of the blog). Blogger is pretty old now;
Substack is more cutting edge. Maybe some day I will try that. But
I am used to Blogger, so I suppose that I will stick with it, as long
as it’s around.
Like Quora, you can make money posting on Blogger
(in theory, i.e. advertising). I suspect that it would be pennies
per year, so I don’t see any point in doing so (ok, maybe dimes).
Blogger stats can be rather dubious. I am not
sure about recent years, but in the past bots could be a real
problem. The 1000 readers that you thought you had last week, might
mostly have been the result of an overactive bot or two. Having said
all that, it is still nice to see your Blogger views stats go up.
You just have to take it with a grain of salt.
Does blogging drive book sales? Maybe marginally,
but it is way oversold by social media mavens as a way to sell books
(“you must have a blog with rich content, comrade!”). I have occasionally
had a blog that had a lot of reads that also ticked up sales of a
book that I featured at the end of the blog. But we are talking 1
book for every 1000 blog reads, or ratios like that. So, basically
one just blogs for love of writing.
Also like Quora, I suspect the LLMs (large
language models) scour blogger and the like for content. So, while
you may not be making money for yourself, you might be making money for
Google. Hmmmm.
8) Facebook
Facebook is mostly good for family stuff, in my
experience. Dogs, cats, children – maybe we should reverse the
order.
There are Facebook pages for businesses. We have
a Dodecahedron Books Facebook page, but I don’t use it as much as
perhaps I should. Unfortunately, in my opinion, the Facebook
business page user interface has become such a dog’s breakfast that
it is difficult to navigate. Which is too bad, because readers have
sometimes contacted me via that route. So, I do try to keep active,
at least for their sake, but it is hard.
The regular Facebook user interface is somewhat
better than that of the business pages. But, even they have become
so plugged-up with “sponsored content” and the like, that it is
rather discouraging. But, I check in, when I can, and will try to
keep doing so. The fact that you can keep in touch with family,
friends and ex-workmates from across the country, is rather charming.
X, formerly known as
Twitter
Well, you can blast Twitter posts advertising your
books. Maybe they do some good – I’m not sure. If so, the
effect is, shall we say, rather limited. But, hope springs eternal.
But X is still
good for a laugh, as long as you don’t sink too much time into it,
and you don’t take it very seriously.
******************************************************************
As promised above, here are some book plugs:
Kati of Terra Book 1 – Escape from the Drowned
Planet
Amazon
U.S: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00811WVXO
Amazon
U.K.: http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Canada: https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Germany: https://www.amazon.de/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Netherlands:
https://www.amazon.nl/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Italy: https://www.amazon.it/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Australia: https://www.amazon.com.au/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Japan: https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
India: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Spain: https://www.amazon.es/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon France:
https://www.amazon.fr/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Mexico: https://www.amazon.com.mx/dp/B00811WVXO
Amazon
Brazil:
https://www.amazon.com.br/dp/B00811WVXO
In
saving her small son from alien abductors, a 24-year-old Earth woman,
Katie, finds herself abducted instead. She awakens from a
drug-induced coma on a spaceship, in a room full of children, both
human and alien, and two other women, younger than she is. The young
women adapt to the situation as best they can, keeping the youngsters
calm and entertained. But, when a drugged alien man wearing a uniform
is added to the captive cargo, it becomes clear that this is an
intergalactic slave operation.
She finds herself on a strange world,
with a somewhat deranged personality, quite possibly a killer, in her
head, and partnered with a man from an advanced civilization who
abhors killing. He is a Federation Peace Officer, captured by the
slavers while attempting to bring them to justice. His task is
complicated by the fact that he has sworn to avoid the taking of
sentient life during the performance of his duties. He can and does,
however, make vigorous use of non-lethal weaponry. Since, before
leaving the ship, Katie had promised to help her co-captives gain
their liberty, she and the alien peace officer find that they have a
common cause.
But first they must find their way off
the primitive planet and get to the Federated Civilization, avoiding
the slavers who have been left on the planet to re-capture them.
Their flight is complicated by the fact that the planet has had a
global warming catastrophe some centuries back – the locals refer
to it as the Drowned World. This has forced the inhabitants to revert
to a pre-industrial state of development; however, they are a wily
and resourceful people, mostly helpful, but they can also be
dangerous.
Kati (to mark her escape, she adopts a
slight name change) and Mikal seek a Federation beacon, which had
been hidden on this planet ages ago, to aid in situations such as
this, (in accord with a longstanding Federation policy for fringe
worlds). They must embark on an arduous trek across two continents
and an ocean, seeking the temple that holds the beacon. They travel
on foot, by cart, by riverboat, by tall sailing ship, and on pack
animals, always pursued by the dangerous slavers.
They must rely on their wits, guile,
charm and acting abilities to avoid recapture, while their chasers
have advanced technology and ruthlessness on their side. Fortunately,
they are able to make many friends who help them along the way, and
their quest becomes a series of adventures, both frightening and
funny, and involving a cast of engaging characters.
To complicate matters, Kati finds
herself falling in love with Mikal, the strange, handsome and amusing
alien. He seems to be reciprocating, though they both struggle
against an untimely romantic entanglement.
Will Kati and Mikal escape from the
Drowned Planet? Can they ultimately bring the slavers to justice, as
Mikal has sworn to do? Can they free the remaining captives of the
slavers, as Kati has promised to do? Read this book and the rest of
the series to find out all.
At about 200,000 words (equivalent to
a paperback of about 400 pages), the book is an excellent value.
The Sappers' War: 12th Field Company Royal
Canadian Engineers, Oct 1943 to Sept 1945
What follows is a review of the
history of the 12th Field Company, Royal Canadian Engineers,
primarily relating to the time that the company was in the Italian
and Northwestern European theatres during World War II. Though the
book focuses on the experiences of a particular company of Canadian
military engineers, it also discusses some of the wider issues of the
second world war and how it affected the people who lived through the
era, civilian and military. Among those are my father (a sapper or
military engineer) and mother (a war worker in wartime Britain and
ultimately a war bride).
Thus, this is meant to be an
informal and unofficial history of the company, written by an
interested party in an effort to understand what these men went
through during this period, and how that experience affected them and
other people who lived through the war. The military aspects of the
company's history are there (e.g. fighting, building bridges,
detecting mines, maintaining routes), as are the cultural factors
that influenced them and their times (e.g. the movies that they
watched, the drinking they did, the many diseases they faced, their
interactions with the Italian, British and other civilians that they
lived among, their worries for the future). Some focus on life on the
British home front is also given, via the experiences of my mother
and her family.
Since many people had family and relations
that lived during this time, it is my hope that the account will be
of general interest to them, and to any that have a particular
interest in this critical interval in history. Also, though the text
relates specifically to Canadian sappers, I believe that many of the
experiences will be common to the soldiers and loved ones of other
nations who lived through the war, especially Americans and those
from Britain and the British Commonwealth.
The primary
sources of this document are the 12th Field Company War Diaries and
related orders, with some material from The History of the
Corps of Royal Canadian Engineers, Volume 2 as well as
various official histories by the Department of National Defence.
Various other published sources are used as well, especially when
discussing the wider issues of the war or the army experience (e.g.
Churchill’s history of the war) , or conversely when relating very
specific episodes of the war (e.g. Popski’s Private Army in late
1944). Personal accounts of my father’s or mother’s stories also
augment the narrative. I have tried to fit those in during
appropriate time periods, though some stories are more general and
have therefore don’t necessarily relate to the time period being
discussed. Nonetheless, they do help capture the essence of “being
there” during the war years.
The War Diary is a day by
day account of the primary activities of a given unit, as recorded by
personnel in the headquarters staff of that unit, and signed off by
the commander of the unit. As such, it is an official record, though
the writers often brought a bit of their own character into the
document. Naturally, as a relatively brief document it can’t hope
to capture the complexity of the individual stories of 280 or so men,
so the family lore generally has no corresponding entry in the War
Diary, though there are sometimes tantalizing hints and
near-verifications of these personal accounts.
There are a
number of other sources for the book, from official histories to
popular history books. I include quotations and references from these
works (an eclectic mix), as I believe that they also shed light on
different aspects of this period of time, and besides that, are just
interesting accounts, in and of themselves.
U.S.:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
U.K.:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Germany:
https://www.amazon.de/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
France:
https://www.amazon.fr/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Spain:
https://www.amazon.es/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Italy:
https://www.amazon.it/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Netherlands:
https://www.amazon.nl/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Japan:
https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Brazil:
https://www.amazon.com.br/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Canada:
https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Mexico:
https://www.amazon.com.mx/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
Australia:
https://www.amazon.com.au/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
India:
https://www.amazon.in/dp/B09HSXN6Q2
A Summer Working on the Railroad
What follows is an account of a few weeks one long-ago summer, when I
was 19 and was working for the Canadian National Railway (CNR) on a
railroad construction gang, in the wilds of north-central British
Columbia, Canada.
The journal is in the
form of a letter, that was never sent. Decades later, I think it has
an interesting historical resonance. At times I come off like a
callow youth – I plead guilty as charged. I swore a lot more in
those days than I do now, but in places the writing is surprisingly
good, at least in my humble opinion. And the story has a compelling
narrative arc.
There were a lot of
interesting and dramatic events that occurred – a number of
industrial accidents being the most serious. There were also some
colorful characters on the crew, which resulted in some dramatic and
at times amusing conflicts and altercations. I perhaps flatter myself
by including myself in that number. Or perhaps I condemn myself –
I’m not sure.
So, if you want to be
reminded of one of those summer jobs that was kind of life-changing,
read on. My story may just kick-start some memories of your own.
The memoir/journal is about 9,000
words, a length that can usually be read in an hour or so. It is
priced at 99 cents U.S. (equivalent in other currencies) and is free
on Kindle Unlimited. Periodically, it will be offered as a free
promotion.
U.S.:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CN661P8Z
UK:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Canada:
https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Australia:
https://www.amazon.com.au/dp/B0CN661P8Z
India:
https://www.amazon.in/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Germany:
https://www.amazon.de/dp/B0CN661P8Z
France:
https://www.amazon.fr/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Spain:
https://www.amazon.es/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Italy:
https://www.amazon.it/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Netherlands:
https://www.amazon.nl/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Japan:
https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Brazil:
https://www.amazon.com.br/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Mexico:
https://www.amazon.com.mx/dp/B0CN661P8Z
Three Love Stories
Here are three stories, all dealing
with the theme of romantic love. They encompass the feelings we all
recognize from our experiences of love: lust and desire, jealousy and
betrayal, confusion and certainty, forgiveness and reconciliation,
loss and rebirth. They even suggest that love might get a little help
from those mysterious realms beyond our normal, everyday life. Love
is, after all, one of the most magical of all transformations that we
mortals can undergo.
Three
Love Stories
Amazon
U.S.: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
U.K.: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon Germany:
https://www.amazon.de/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
France: https://www.amazon.fr/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Canada: https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Australia: https://www.amazon.com.au/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Italy: https://www.amazon.it/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Spain: https://www.amazon.es/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Netherlands: https://www.amazon.nl/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Japan: https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Brazil: https://www.amazon.com.br/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
Mexico: https://www.amazon.com.mx/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
Amazon
India: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B01BLVSZ2G
It should be noted that these three
stories have been previously published, but we wanted to bundle them
together, for a number of reasons.
-
Firstly, they are thematically
connected - they all concern the joys, pains and triumphs of
romantic love.
-
Secondly, the first two stories are
connected by plot and character - Love at the Lake: Part 2
(published separately as “A Mid-Summer Morning’s Dream at the
Lake”) tells the story of what happens later to the characters
embroiled in the jealousy and betrayal of Love at the Lake: Part
1. Characters can sometimes take on a life of their own, and
insist that the writer tell their whole story - that’s just what
happened here. Love and Rebirth on the Prairie follows
different characters, but they too are searching for love within the
complexities of family drama with a history of (possible) betrayal.
-
And finally, this bundling gives us a
way to package the stories in a more economical and convenient form
for our valued readers - three stories for one low price. In the
future, we hope to add even more to this collection of love stories!
Note that in 2022 and 2023 the
biggest cause of differences between the two models is simply given
as “Other changes”. This is vague – a description like “Other
changes” can hide a lot. After all, the “Other Changes” are precisely
what most people are wondering about.
